It caught a mistake in my own review.
Before building the tool, I reviewed issue #424 by hand: 30 scoring runs, the root cause traced through four files, and all 191 open PRs checked against it. That review took about 1.5 hours and became the tool's test target.
My review said #415 only partly fixes the bug.
The tool said #415 fixes it fully. I opened the diff: #415 adds resolve_selected_projects, which rebuilds each selected project from the fetched data. The tool was right.
It also found #242, a partial fix that my review missed.
Both PRs touch the exact lines where the bug lives, which is why the shortlist caught them. The verdicts are labelled as judged from the diff, because nothing was run.